Fuck Me Eyes

Purposefully titularly hidden until its day of release, “Fuck Me Eyes” is the second single off Cain’s sophomore album, Willoughby Tucker, I’ll Always Love You. Making a return to the more ‘synth-pop’ sound of previous tracks like “Crush” and “American Teenager,” the song arrives at a drastic change from the lead single, “Nettles.”

Originally teased as far back as 2020 via short snippets on Instagram Livestreams and TikTok videos long before its official debut, the title of the song was deliberately withheld until release, with Cain’s manager, Marlee, actively misleading fans in the comments of the single announcement to preserve the surprise of sorts before the set release date of July 2nd, 2025.

The song narrates Ethel’s tumultuous emotions towards Holly Reddick, a fellow classmate constantly hanging around Willoughby Tucker who Ethel assumes must be in love with the girl.